Rated
Apr 28 2008
•
1 review
•
catholic
• pbs.org
From the page: "
Reviving 'cafeteria Catholics'JEFFREY BROWN: In terms of other things, aside from this scandal, where there the disconnectedness shows up between American practices and the teachings of the church, does the church look at this as a kind of pick-and-choose?
Is that how American Catholics think about their religion, pick and choose what we want from the teachings? And how does the church respond? What does the pope say?
DAVID GIBSON: That we're all cafeteria Catholics, essentially, you know, and that has been kind of the label that's been applied to Catholics in the United States. And I think it's fair enough.
It's kind of a pejorative label, but I think people, also, from left to right, to use those kinds of crude labels, I think people do pick and choose to a great degree the teachings that they want to emphasize.
They'll listen. The pope is going to come again and he's going to give a very broad-ranging message on the wide-ranging teachings and traditions of the church. And people are going to hear, to a degree, what they want to hear or what resonates with them.
And they're going to disregard what they don't want to hear, be it on immigration and the death penalty, be it on abortion, euthanasia, stem cell, et cetera.
That's always been a difficulty for the Vatican; it's a difficulty for any religious leader, frankly. You're always coming and presenting a very high ideal and a wide-ranging tradition and one that goes very deeply. And that's just always a tension, frankly, that's going to be there.
And I think we have to understand that, that there's -- you know, we're always talking about the tensions between Rome and the American church. And they exist. And there are bad tensions and there are good tensions."-----------------------------------------------------------Read all the analysis, wrapups and commentaries about the Papal visit to America. Its all about what the people want vs. what the hierarchy wants vs what each one wants the other to want, etc
Nowhere is there anything except scant mention of what God has already told us plainly and clearly in His holy word what He wants of us. Pray for them, may God have mercy.