

The story: I post a suggestion to the Stumbleupon Features forum, proposing that the users at Stumbleupon be allowed a very simple freedom granted to users at many blogging services - to be able to choose the titles of their own blogs. My own blog, for example, instead of being named
josephdunphy's blog - Stumbleuponwhich, let's face it, looks kind of generic and more than a little shoddy (not even presenting the reader with anything resembling correct English capitalization), would appear under the title
The Abyss: Joseph Dunphy's Reviews and Commentary at StumbleuponWhile this was hardly the most radical proposal to have ever been heard in a user forum, it was fought by a group of users who expressed a belief that their fellow users at Stumbleupon would not be up to handling a freedom that simple. Suggesting that said fellow users lacked the intelligence, maturity, and good taste needed to select a few words appearing atop a browser page, our friends were willing to fight to keep their fellow users from enjoying the freedom to choose those words for themselves, in effect arguing that Stumbleupon should treat its own adult users (many of them old enough to be well into middle age or beyond) as if they were children. The argument advanced in support of this were - interesting - to put it gently, and at times, their behavior even more so, as one can see documented in the screenshots accompanying the story; petty, underhanded, and at times, memorably vicious, even by Internet standards.
This is page that I wrote on the Stumbleupon and eBay googlegroup documenting the story of how a policy decision here at Stumbleupon would seem to have been made in all of its absurdity, complete with screenshots, showing how the DIY moderation found in Stumbleupon's forums made matters worse, not better. Why I will never take part in such a discussion in a Stumbleupon forum, again, and why I would recommend that you think twice before doing so, yourself.

Note: Lokito, who I see has chimed in, was one of the participants in what passed for a debate on this point, during which our 15 year old friend decided to share with us the benefit of his many years of experience. As you can see, he took great offense at the thought that a mere adult would dare to talk back to him and point out the numerous flaws in arguments that were remarkably poorly thought out, even by high school standards. Somebody had been badly overindulged, but don't take my word for it. Take a good look at his contributions, and decide for yourself just how seriously his point of view deserves to be taken. As he took the time to write on July 3 of this year, "I haven't had someone thumb me up in many months. I'm sort of proud of that, in a way."
I don't doubt it

...
continued