Rated
Aug 23
•
2 reviews
•
history, psychology
• historycooperative.org
barbara h rosenwein
emotional communities
. . . People lived--and live--in what I propose to call "emotional communities." These are precisely the same as social communities--families, neighborhoods, parliaments, guilds, monasteries, parish church memberships--but the researcher looking at them seeks above all to uncover systems of feeling: what these communities (and the individuals within them) define and assess as valuable or harmful to them; the evaluations that they make about others' emotions; the nature of the affective bonds between people that they recognize; and the modes of emotional expression that they expect, encourage, tolerate, and deplore.
I further propose that people move (and moved) continually from one such community to another--from taverns to law courts, say--adjusting their emotional displays and their judgments of weal and woe (with greater and lesser degrees of success) to these different environments. As Lyndal Roper has put it, "competing cultures [may be seen in the] same individual man [or woman]." There are two points here: not only does every society call forth, shape, constrain, and express emotions differently, but even within the same society contradictory values and models, not to mention deviant individuals, find their place. John Baldwin has pointed to the multiple voices in medieval discourses on sex. I suggest that we recognize the possibility of finding similar varieties, as well as convergences, in emotional feeling and expression. . . .
The grand narrative that has dominated emotions scholarship cannot stand. It is based on a debunked theory of the emotions and its concomitant, but flawed, notion of progressive self-restraint. Jettisoning the hydraulic view does not mean that one new approach must take over: there are plenty of issues to consider and a variety of useful modes of attack, no one of which is going to compass the whole field for all periods and every sort of evidence. The new narrative will recognize various emotional styles, emotional communities, emotional outlets, and emotional restraints in every period, and it will consider how and why these have changed over time.
Once we have embarked upon that narrative (and some already have), we may stop worrying about emotions in history and begin to enjoy them.